Export Sales Dashboard – How did it affect the markets? – AgFax

On August 25, the USDA International Agriculture Division launched its weekly export gross sales report utilizing a brand new reporting system. Primarily based on some unreasonable values ​​on this report, common customers of this knowledge are starting to suspect that the report is inaccurate. The USDA rapidly retracted the report and postponed the publication of extra export gross sales reviews. On September 1, 2022, the USDA introduced that it could return to the outdated export gross sales reporting system in order that it may resolve its know-how points. Public reporting of export gross sales knowledge is anticipated to renew on September 15, 2022.

The absence of standard export gross sales reviews raises a minimum of two questions. First, what’s the standing of export gross sales for outdated crop 2021-22 and new crop 2022-23 advertising and marketing years for corn and soybeans? USDA export gross sales knowledge is out there by way of August 11, 2022. Late August and early September are an uncommon time for export gross sales info.

With the outdated crop advertising and marketing yr for corn and soybean ending on August 31, this time interval usually sees outdated crop export commitments canceled or moved from one advertising and marketing yr to a different. Consequently, weekly adjustments in outdated crop export gross sales commitments are sometimes flat or damaging in late August. On the identical time, gross sales of recent crops are often massive in comparison with different weeks of the yr.

Primarily based on the data we have now, the outlook for exports of outdated crops of corn and soybeans in the USA is blended. Corn exports are unlikely to achieve the anticipated advertising and marketing yr totals if unobservable export gross sales commitments in late August observe typical historic patterns. Forecasting new crop export gross sales within the absence of USDA knowledge is harder for the explanations talked about above.

The second and broader query issues the worth of the provision of USDA export gross sales knowledge for agricultural commodity markets. What could be misplaced if export gross sales reviews weren’t launched each week?

It’s clear that the shortage of export gross sales reviews doesn’t forestall exporters from arranging new gross sales. Commerce in agricultural commodities is not going to cease. Nor does it get rid of all public info. Export gross sales reviews are only one knowledge merchandise among the many many reviews offered by the USDA and different sources. Nevertheless, elevated uncertainty about export gross sales might result in some commerce disputes.

Earlier instances during which USDA reviews weren’t launched as a result of federal authorities shutdowns shed some mild on this query. The evaluation of those instances signifies the volatility of the implied choices and subsequently the price of managing the danger utilizing the choices was excessive. Nevertheless, these shutdowns affected practically all USDA knowledge merchandise that are anticipated to have an excellent larger influence.

The standing of US corn and soybean export gross sales

Previous corn and soybean crop gross sales for the 2021-22 advertising and marketing yr have been sturdy, above the earlier 5-year common though under file ranges set within the earlier 2020/21 advertising and marketing yr. The newest US Division of Agriculture (WASDE) world agricultural provide and demand estimates from the August 2021/22 venture. US exports are 2,450 million bushels for corn and a pair of,160 million bushels for soybeans.

The info from the Export Gross sales report helps market watchers to determine whether or not precise exports are prone to attain the anticipated ranges of WASDE. This knowledge proven in Determine 1 signifies that US exports are prone to attain the anticipated degree of WASDE for soybeans, however not for corn. Complete soybean export commitments (exports cumulative to knowledge plus pending gross sales) have been roughly 2,190 million bushels or 30 million bushels above the extent anticipated for WASDE. Complete corn export commitments have been about 2,400 million bushels, or 50 million bushels, lower than the extent anticipated for WASDE.

Click on on the picture to enlarge

What doubtless occurred within the final three weeks of the advertising and marketing yr for which the info was reported? Sometimes, many of the remaining remaining gross sales are transformed into precise exports, however some gross sales of older crops beforehand introduced are canceled or postponed to the advertising and marketing yr of recent crops.

The online result’s that there isn’t any weekly change in export commitments, as evidenced by the five-year common proven in Determine 1. In some years, export commitments decline on the finish of the advertising and marketing yr. For instance, 2020/21 corn export gross sales commitments fell by about 15 million bushels within the final three weeks of the advertising and marketing yr.

Within the absence of precise export gross sales reviews from the USDA, it’s unreasonable to count on 50 million bushels in corn export gross sales. In the meantime, 2021/22 soybean export gross sales will attain WASDE projected ranges even when a few of the excellent gross sales commitments within the remaining weeks of the advertising and marketing yr are cancelled. The plain limitation of this conclusion is that it assumes that the current shall be much like the previous.

It’s troublesome to find out new crop export gross sales within the absence of standard weekly export gross sales knowledge. The primary weeks of a brand new advertising and marketing yr are often one of many busiest occasions of the yr for export gross sales. For instance, the common weekly change in export gross sales commitments within the first 5 weeks of a brand new advertising and marketing yr noticed between 2016 and 2020 is about 57 million bushels per week for corn and simply over 75 million bushels for soybeans.

The vary of historic outcomes throughout this era is massive. The lack of USDA export gross sales knowledge throughout late August and early September signifies larger uncertainty in regards to the state of export demand throughout a interval when export demand could also be risky.

What’s misplaced when export gross sales usually are not reported?

The final rationale for offering USDA info on agricultural commodity markets is as follows: Higher details about provide and demand situations permits merchants to find market costs that extra precisely replicate the worth of these commodities. Extra correct pricing then improves useful resource allocation choices alongside the provision chain.

Extra correct pricing can take two broad kinds: value ranges and value volatility. Financial evaluation has proven that the discharge of USDA reviews, particularly the month-to-month WASDE reviews, causes the noticed value ranges to be adjusted, indicating that the reviews comprise useful details about basic provide and demand situations. Research have additionally proven that expectations about value volatility, represented by choice costs, are decrease when reporting is made.

However what occurs when this public info shouldn’t be obtainable? This can be a troublesome query to reply as a result of the USDA has constantly offered public info for commodity markets because the nineteenth century. Detailed knowledge akin to that in WASDE and export gross sales reviews has been obtainable because the Seventies.

Nevertheless, two latest research checked out distinctive instances the place the federal authorities shutdown halted the discharge of WASDE reviews for October 2013 and January 2019. These research discovered no proof that corn and soybean costs have been wrongly priced, however there are some indications of upper market volatility within the absence of those reviews. Particularly, the decline within the implied volatility of choices and choice costs that usually follows the discharge of USDA reviews in October 2013 and January 2019 was not noticed.

The momentary absence of USDA export gross sales reviews might have an identical impact as did lacking WASDE reviews. Nevertheless, you will need to notice that export gross sales knowledge is just one piece of market-relevant info; The WASDE report accommodates a extra complete image of provide and demand for commodities. There could also be a slight uptick in value volatility within the absence of export gross sales reviews over the subsequent few weeks and extra volatility on September fifteenth when export gross sales reviews resume as market costs are reconciled with new knowledge.

Joe Janzin